About the book
For thirty years the public story of the 1944–45 campaign was of an alliance that fought as one. David Irving went to what the commanders wrote at the time, and found a second war running inside the first. Eisenhower is trying to hold a coalition together. Montgomery wants command of the whole land battle and keeps saying so. Patton believes Eisenhower has sold out to the British. Bradley, mild in public, lets Patton attack without leave (“I won’t listen for the telephone”) and privately fears the Germans can hold out until 1946.
The book runs from Eisenhower’s arrival in London in January 1944 through Normandy, Arnhem, the Battle of the Bulge and the Rhine to the halt on the Elbe. At each stage it follows the argument that decided it: who controls the bombers, which army gets the fuel, who commands on the ground, and whether to take Berlin.
The diaries behind it
Irving’s chief find was the diary of Lieutenant General Everett Hughes, Eisenhower’s old friend and private inspector. Its nine hundred pages had sat unread in the Library of Congress because nobody could decipher the handwriting. Beside it he sets the diary of Kay Summersby, Eisenhower’s personal assistant, a detailed daily record that Irving found far shrewder than her two published books. He also uses the pages cut from Harry Butcher’s published diary, Patton’s diary and Montgomery’s handwritten letters to Brooke. The private remarks are left in, down to Eisenhower shouting into the telephone that he is “tired of dealing with a lot of prima donnas”.
What you will find in it
- Omaha Beach, where Brigadier General Norman Cota walked the sand under fire to get the men off it. The Washington Post said the scene “left this reader clutching the book with excitement”.
- The morning of 16 December 1944. As the Battle of the Bulge opened, Eisenhower was at his valet’s wedding at Versailles, Montgomery was on a golf course, and Bradley and Hodges were being measured for shotguns.
- Montgomery’s near-dismissal. That December Eisenhower was on the point of asking for his relief. Montgomery’s chief of staff flew in to stop the message, and Montgomery signed his apology “Your very devoted subordinate”.
- The Berlin decision, from Eisenhower’s phrase that Berlin was “the main prize” to the order that stopped the Ninth Army on the Elbe, about sixty miles short.
Irving does not spare the campaign’s uncomfortable side: American tanks outgunned by the German Panther, French civilians killed by Allied bombing, and 454 American soldiers sentenced to death by courts-martial after D-Day.
Nor does he take one general’s part. He defends Montgomery’s Normandy plan, says his reports were untrue, and ends by calling him and Eisenhower “a match for each other”. The Baltimore Sunday Sun called the book “conspicuously unbiased”.
This edition
First published in New York in 1981. The appendix prints in full John Lukacs’s hostile New York Times review of that year, followed by Irving’s reply, The 2026 Irving Books edition also has photographs, a map, the full list of archival sources in the United States, Britain and Canada, and an index.